You may wonder how to get that delicious tomato sauce that compliments your favorite margarita or delicious turkey?

It is easy enough if you have a simple yet useful kitchen item such as a food mill at your disposal.

But you still might be a bit puzzled by how to choose the right one.

Not to worry, we are here to help you choose the best food mill for tomatoes.

Top 5 Best Food Mill for Tomatoes

1. Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill
2. OXO Good Grips Food Mill
3. Winco Food Mill
4. GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill
5. Mirro 50024 Foley Food Mill Cookware

Food Mill for Tomatoes Buying Guide

Let’s start with what exactly is a food mill? A food mill is a very useful kitchen device that is used for grinding, mashing soft foods, and separating the food from the seeds and skins. A food mill consists of three parts such as a bowl, a bottom plate with holes, and a handle with a bent metal blade that weighs upon food and presses it to go through holes. A bottom plate can be an invariable part, or you can change it to another one that has holes of different sizes.

Food mills are often used to grind or puree foods such as soups, sauce, and mash boiled potatoes, carrots, and other vegetables. Also, it’s used for sieving cold and hot foods for canning or making preserves, as well as getting rid of seeds, skins, and stems to have delicious tomato sauce.

To get that desirable smooth sauce, with the help of a food mill, you need to pick the right tomatoes. The best is to choose extra fleshy, or a little bit of bruised tomatoes as you will need as little effort as possible to smash them in the mill. You have to wash the tomatoes, and if they’re too big, it’s preferable to chop them in halves or even quarters. It’s better to cut aside all parts of tomatoes that are extra bruised.

Then, you need to pick a suitable bowl, install a food mill and begin sieving. All the pulp of tomatoes and juice will drop in the bowl. All the scraps will be left in your mill, so after you’re finished with sieving, you will need to throw the scraps away.

Another way to get the smooth consistency of the sauce is to pick more thick tomatoes and boil or steam them for a couple of minutes. In that way, the skin will be ripped, and all that you will need to get rid of are seeds and stems.

Wash the tomatoes, make little cuts on the skin, and put them in the saucepan. Generally, you will need no more than 5 minutes for the skin to start rolling up. Then, you need to pick up the tomatoes and put them into another bowl with cold water. Let them sit there for a few minutes. After that, gently remove all the skin and put the tomatoes into the food mill.

Important features

The majority of the food mills have the same features, but still, some parts of them may differ. So when you’re choosing the right one for you, you need to pay attention to such characteristics as a handle and hooks for holding onto a bowl, interchangeable disks, blade that is located close to the disk, “grabbing” edges of the perforated holes in the disks, and easy assembly.

Firstly, your food mill should definitely have a handle and hooks for holding onto a bowl. It’ll make the whole process way easier and less tiresome for you to clean afterwards. It would be better if you could test whether it sits firmly on the bowl or not.

Secondly, interchangeable disks will come in handy more often than not as you may want to not only sieve tomatoes but cook mashed potatoes or make delicious apple sauce.

Thirdly, you need to pay attention to the close position of the blade to the disk. It is important because you definitely don’t want a residue of half-sieved tomatoes to be at the bottom of your bowl. It may be the case if the blade is located too far from the disk and doesn’t push the tomato through the holes. Another thing that might help here is “grabbing” edges of the perforated holes in the disks. If the edges of those holes are inside the food mill, they will get a hold of the tomatoes and help the blade to do its job.

Lastly, you don’t want spend ages assembling and disassembling your food mill. So, look for those that are easily reassembled and taken apart to be cleaned efficiently. Therefore, let us help you to pick the best food mill for tomatoes.

Best Food Mill for Tomatoes Reviews

Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill

Pros

• Made from stainless steel
• Has 3 grinding discs: fine, medium, coarse
• Successfully separates seeds and skins from the pulp

Cons

• Require a bit of brute force to disassemble the discs

See price @ Amazon

Best features and specs

Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill is a perfectly versatile kitchen item that will save you a lot of time and effort. You don’t have to remove the skins of tomatoes beforehand. This food mill will remove seeds and skins effortlessly and give you juicy pulp. As it has a handle and two end clips, it will grip the edges of the saucepan or a bowl that you will put under the food mill.

User impressions

Users are quite impressed with Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill due to its durability, but some users note that it has rather weak welding points, which could break if the mill isn’t used properly. Some users also say that Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill doesn’t have a wire to remove the pulp from the underside, so you’re going to have to do it manually.

What we think

What we liked the most about Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill is that it has 3 grinding discs. Fine is good for making smooth jellies, creamy, delicate sauces, and baby food. Medium is good for mouthwatering apple sauce, vegetable soups, and tomato sauce. And Coarse that will help you with sauces that have bits of vegetables and mashed potatoes. Having a highly multifunctional food mill is always an advantage.

Bottomline

Granite Ware Stainless Steel Deluxe Food Mill is a perfect choice for someone who is looking for a versatile kitchen tool. Choose the right saucepan or bowl, put the food mill on the top, and start pureeing tomatoes. We recommend the medium disc for the tomatoes here, but you can choose between fine, medium and coarse discs  according to your preferred sauce texture and then simply enjoy the process. Keep in mind that it may be a bit challenging for you to change discs or take them apart before washing.

OXO Good Grips Food Mill

Pros

• Has 3 grinding discs: fine, medium, coarse
• Easily change the discs or disassemble the parts before washing
• Has the OXO Better Guarantee
• Versatile in terms of grinding a variety of foods, both cold and hot

Cons

• None that we know of

See price @ Amazon

Best features and specs

For people who cook a lot, an item that is well-designed and that doesn’t require a lot of effort to use is a must-have. That’s why OXO Good Grips Food Mill is a good thing to have in your kitchen. This food mill has legs that fit over a range of bowls and then these legs flip in for easy storage. It also has three discs so that you can pick which texture you want to have in the end.

User impressions

Users like OXO Good Grips Food Mill for its ability to separate mesh from seeds and skin. Some users also note that with the smallest disc, you can even remove blackberry seeds. OXO Good Grips Food Mill is a perfect appliance for someone who has arthritis or just sore hands because you don’t need to use force to use it.

What we think

There are a few things that we liked the most about OXO Good Grips Food Mill. The first is that you have an OXO Better Guarantee, which might come in handy if it is something wrong with your food mill down the line. The second is that it has a stainless steel bowl that is designed to mash and grind hot and cold products. The third is that vegetables such as tomatoes and beets don’t stain and leave any color on food mill walls, which is an added plus for cleaning.

Bottomline

OXO Good Grips Food Mill is a perfect choice for someone who is looking for a well-designed food mill with flippable legs for easy storage. The stainless steel bowl lets you mash and grind cold and hot products in it without leaving colorful stains on the food mill walls. Also, having a guarantee directly from the manufacturer is always a nice bonus.

Winco Food Mill

Pros

• Rust and stains resistant
• Easy to assemble and disassemble
• Works best with pre-cooked vegetables and fruits

Cons

• Tends to miss crushed pulp if you don’t swipe the bottom of the bowl
• Doesn’t work for heavy cooking

See price @ Amazon

Best features and specs

What you want from the time you spend while cooking is to be stress-free or less stressful at least. Winco Food Mill will help you in preparing sauces, jellies, soups, and purees. As this food mill is resistant to rust and stains, it will remain your helper in the kitchen for a long time.

User impressions

Users say that Winco Food Mill has a very convenient shape that makes it very easy to use, although some users note that it feels much slower than other mills. Other users are also impressed with how easy it is to clean.

What we think

Winco Food Mill works the best with already pre-cooked vegetables and fruits. You might need to do a few extra actions before putting tomatoes in the food mill and start sieving them. Also, you need to remember that you have to swipe the bowl regularly if you want all of the pulp to be properly processed.

Bottomline

Winco Food Mill is a perfect choice for someone who is looking for a food mill that works specifically well with pre-cooked vegetables and fruits. This food mill is rust and stain resistant and is easy to assemble and disassemble before washing. If you don’t want to spend extra time on pre-cooking food before grinding it, you may skip to the next one on the list.

GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill

Pros

• Designed specifically for making sauces
• Extremely easy to use and assemble

Cons

• A little bit pricey

See price @ Amazon

Best features and specs

It is in the human nature to be inclined to choose the best item from several options possible, especially when we are talking about kitchen items, as you want them to last forever. GEFU specializes in top-quality, reliable kitchen items that will help you in cooking delicious dishes for your friends and family. GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill will help you in removing seeds, skins, and stems from vegetables and provide you with smooth pulp.

User impressions

Users like GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill for its build quality and durability. Some users also say that it’s very easy to use and are very impressed with how fast it works with cooked tomatoes. Most users agree that GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill is the best food mill they’ve ever had.

What we think

We found GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill extremely useful in ceasing food from moving and removing the accumulated pulp with the help of a pulp scraper. Also, we liked that it is unbelievably easy to make tomato and other sauces, jams, soups, compotes, and baby food.

Bottomline

GEFU Stainless Steel Food Mill is a perfect choice for someone who is looking for a reliable and durable food mill that is designed specifically for making smooth and delicious sauces.

Mirro 50024 Foley Food Mill Cookware

Pros

• Made from stainless steel
• Designed for mashing, straining, grating, and ricing food

Cons

• The knob of the handle might leave some marks on the user’s hand
• Blades don’t evenly meet and leave a lot of food untouched

See price @ Amazon

Best features and specs

Mirro 50024 Foley Food Mill Cookware is a good choice when all you want to do is make some tomato or apple sauces. It is very easy to assemble and clean using your dishwasher.

User impressions

Users agree that Mirro 50024 Foley Food Mill Cookware is a pretty durable mill with a light handle, but some users had a negative experience with faulty units. During the first usage, this mill can leave some metal dust in your mesh. Other users note that blades don’t reach the bottom of the mill.

What we think

What we found the most useful about Mirro 50024 Foley Food Mill Cookware is that it is a perfect tool for ricing food as it allows you to save the most nutrients from vegetables. Also, it has an easy-hold handle for an enhanced stability that allows you to keep all things in place.

Bottomline

Mirro 50024 Foley Food Mill Cookware is a perfect choice for someone who is looking to prepare healthy and nutrient-rich tomato and apple sauces.